2003 Eddie Reed Match Play Championship (21st
Annual)
7th Event of 2003 Season, 2nd Major Event
April through October, 2003

Jeff Hazel and Paul Zingg met in the finals of the Eddie Reed
Championship Flight. Paul eked
out a 1-up win. This photo was taken on the first tee of Black Horse
during the Monterey trip on July 27, 2004. The two met here a month later
to play their finals match.

There's a lot of love in this club. Some would say too much. Nevertheless
Scott Meredith and Kelly Alvarez both fought a good battle at Paradise Valley.
Kelly came away with a 2-up win over defending champion Scott.
Championship Flight:
| ROUND
1 |
QUARTERS |
SEMIS |
FINALS |
CHAMPION |
| by June
1 |
by
July 1 |
by Aug
1 |
by Sept
1 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| 1. Desimone, S (1.4) |
Meadow Club:
|
|
|
| 16. Ikeda, J (11.0)
|
1. Desimone, S (1.4) 6 and 4 |
Rancho Solano:
|
|
|
|
|
|
9. Atkinson, R (2.3) 19th hole
|
|
|
| 8.
Hall, V (8.3) |
9. Atkinson, R (1.4) 2 and 1
|
|
|
|
| 9.
Atkinson, R (1.4) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
12. Hazel, J (5.3) 2 and 1
|
|
| 5.
Webb, D (6.2)
|
Poppy Ridge: |
|
|
|
| 12.
Hazel, J (8.0)
|
12. Hazel, J (8.2) 2up
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
12. Hazel, J (7.1) 24th hole |
|
|
| 4.
Lozow, D (6.6)
|
13. Moers, D (6.0) 3 and 1 |
|
|
|
| 13.
Moers, D (6.1)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
10. Zingg, P (5.3) 1up |
| 6.
Peretti, J (6.3) |
Meadow Club:
|
|
|
|
| 11.
Armstrong, M (7.2)
|
6.
Peretti, J (6.3) 4 and 3 |
Poppy Hills:
|
|
|
|
|
|
14. Carey, C (7.8) 19th hole |
|
|
|
3.
Steppan, M (4.9) |
14. Carey, C (7.7) 3 and 2 |
|
|
|
| 14. Carey, C (6.8)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
10. Zingg, P (5.3) 6 and 5
|
|
| 7. Obana, S (8.6)
|
Franklin Canyon: |
|
|
|
| 10. Zingg, P (5.0)
|
10. Zingg, P (6.0) 19th hole
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
10. Zingg, P (5.6) 3 and 1
|
|
|
| 2.
Lloyd, K (2.8) |
15.
Geiser, S (6.4) 3 and 1
|
|
|
|
|
15.
Geiser, S (7.6)
|
|
|
|
|
() - Indexes not used for championship flight, but interesting to note.
First Flight:
| ROUND
1 |
QUARTERS |
SEMIS |
FINALS |
CHAMPION |
| by June 1 |
by July 1
|
by Aug 1 |
by Sept 1 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| 1. Walburg, A (13.5) |
Peninsula
GCC:
|
|
|
| 16. Sanguinetti, S (9.1)
|
16. Sanguinetti, S (9.0) 2 and 1
|
Peninsula GCC:
|
|
|
|
|
|
16. Sanguinetti, S (8.3) 2 and 1
|
|
|
| 8.
Louie, E (15.7) |
8. Louie, E (15.5) 4 and 2
|
|
|
|
| 9.
Kitchener, M
(11.8) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
16. Sanguinetti, S (8.5) 2 up
|
|
| 5. Powell,
J (16.6)
|
Skywest: |
|
|
|
| 12.
Higaki, P (11.9)
|
5. Powell,
J (16.3) 1up |
|
|
|
|
|
|
13.
Holman, M (12.2) 5 and 4 |
|
|
| 4.
Kang, A (12.9)
|
13.
Holman, M (12.4) 2 and 1 |
|
|
|
| 13.
Holman, M (12.4)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
10. Sakamoto, R (11.8) 2 and 1
|
| 6.
Birnbach, M (11.8) |
Metropolitan GC:
|
|
|
|
| 11. Gallagher, R (13.9)
|
6.
Birnbach, M (11.9) 1up |
Boundary Oak:
|
|
|
|
|
|
3.
Guevara, R (13.1) 2 and 1 |
|
|
|
3.
Guevara, R (12.9) |
3.
Guevara, R (12.6) 5 and 4 |
|
|
|
| 14. Werner, P (10.7)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
10. Sakamoto, R (11.8) 2 and 1
|
|
| 7. Day, J (14.9)
|
Metropolitan GC: |
|
|
|
| 10. Sakamoto, R (12.9)
|
10. Sakamoto, R (12.2) 3 and 2
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
10. Sakamoto, R (12.1) 4 and 3
|
|
|
| 2.
Woods, B (12.0) |
2.
Woods, B (11.7) 6 and 5
|
|
|
|
|
15.
Hong, S (8.6)
|
|
|
|
|
() - Indexes
In match play you must
post. Also read about adjusting conceded
holes.
Second Flight:
| ROUND
1 |
QUARTERS |
SEMIS |
FINALS |
CHAMPION |
| by June 1 |
by July 1
|
by Aug 1 |
by Sept 1 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| 1. Meredith, S (16.1) |
Blue Rock East:
|
|
|
| 16. Tabibian, R (18.8)
|
1. Meredith, S (16.5) 19th hole |
Alameda South:
|
|
|
|
|
|
1. Meredith, S (16.1) 6 and 4
|
|
|
| 8. Furtado,
T (16.1) |
8. Furtado,
T (16.5) 3 and 2
|
|
|
|
| 9. King,
J (26.3) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
1. Meredith, S (15.6) 4 and 3
|
|
| 5. Sternbach,
B (19.4)
|
Metropolitan GC: |
|
|
|
| 12. Lee,
C (24.1)
|
5.
Sternbach, B (17.6) 3 and
2
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
5.
Sternbach, B (16.7) 3 and 1 |
|
|
| 4.
Greenwood, R (17.8)
|
4. Greenwood, R (18.8) 2 and 1
|
|
|
|
| 13.
Desimone, B (25.4)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
2. Alvarez, K (22.0) 2up
|
| 6.
McCaslin, B (28.7) |
Alameda North:
|
|
|
|
| 11.
Crenna, L (21.2)
|
6.
McCaslin, B (24.7) 3 and 1 |
Las Positas:
|
|
|
|
|
|
6.
McCaslin, B (25.3) 20th hole |
|
|
|
3.
Lin, Y (16.8) |
3.
Lin, Y (16.4) 3 and 1 |
|
|
|
| 14. Joe, E (16.6)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
2.
Alvarez, K (22.0) 6 and 4
|
|
| 7. Rose, D (18.2)
|
Las Positas: |
|
|
|
| 10. Wherritt, D (20.1)
|
7. Rose, D (18.3) 2up
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
2.
Alvarez, K (24.1) 3 and 2
|
|
|
| 2.
Alvarez, K (23.2) |
2.
Alvarez, K (24.2) 2 and 1
|
|
|
|
|
15.
Marchant, B (16.1)
|
|
|
|
|
() - Indexes
In match play you must
post. Also read about adjusting conceded
holes.
RECAP OF 2003 TOURNAMENT:
Round 1 of Eddie Reed Tournament Completed
So far it's been a very odd Eddie Reed tournament. Major upsets occurred
in the Championship flight as seeds, #2, #3, #4, and #5 were knocked out
in round 1. In
the first flight the #1 and #4 seeds were ousted. In the second flight
not one upset occurred. This Round 1 story from Jim Peretti:"The Mike Armstrong vs. Jim Peretti match took
place at the newly renovated Metropolitan GC. On the 4th hole (Long
difficult par 4, #1 handicap hole) Armstrong rolls in 65 ft putt for birdie.
The pressure was on and Peretti, 20 feet away, drains a tricky uphill putt
from the fringe over huge hump, down the hill, with a 15 foot break around
the cup to half the hole. Armstrong cusses Peretti all the way to 5th hole!"
Round 2 Eddie Reed Results Online
All Round
2 Matches have now been completed. Once again there have been
monumental upsets. First and foremost is defending champion and #1 seed
Steve Desimone's loss to newcomer Ryan Atkinson. Steve was going for his
4th championship in the past 5 years. Ryan had 5 birdies at
the Meadow Club and won his match on the 19th hole. Steve shot a lower
score, but had no birdies on the day. This is one of the club's all-time
upsets. Another upset was Chad Carey's win
over Jim Peretti, also won on the 19th hole at the Meadow Club. Chad is this
season's giant-killer. Chad ousted #3 seed Mark Steppan in the opening
round, before taking out Jim in round 2. The highest remaining seed in the
Championship flight is Ryan Atkinson, at #9. It's all up for grabs. One
more peculiarity to the Championship flight is that all remaining
players have survived matches which have gone extra holes. Jeff Hazel
survived a match with Dave Moers which went 24 holes! In the first
flight Steve Sanguinetti, the #16 seed, upset Ed Louie (#8 seed). Mark
Holman, also an underdog, blazed past Jerry Powell 5 and 4. Ross
Sakamoto produced the second major shocker of the 2nd round, by ousting
#2 seed and 2001 champion Barry Woods, with a 4 and 3 win. Ross is
generally too nice of a guy to do something so brazen. Perhaps Ross has
developed a mean streak of late. Rick Guevara
is the highest remaining first flight seed, at #3. Rick edged Mike
Birnbach 2 and 1. The second flight contains Scott Meredith, the only
remaining #1 seed. Scott flew past Tom Furtado 6 and 4. Bob Sternbach
faced Russell Greenwood in the most heated match of the 2003 tournament.
Russell had caught Bob unwittingly grounding his club during the Kooman
Boycheff tournament, this mistake had cost Bob a first place finish. Bob
avenged his detractor in their match with a 3 and 1 win. Rounding out
the tournament, Boyd McCaslin slipped past Yoch Lin on the 20th hole,
and Kelly Alvarez utilized his lucky Las Positas course to finish off
unsuspecting Dave Rose.
Round 3: Eddie Reed Finals Set
All Round 3 Semifinals matches have now been completed.
The trend of upsets continued into the semifinals. Underdogs won half of
the six semifinals matches. In the Championship flight Jeff Hazel (12th
seed) slipped past Ryan Atkinson (9th seed) in a very close match which
ended 2 and 1. Jeff will face Paul Zingg (10th seed) who defeated Chad
Carey (14th seed) 6 and 5. The final pits two past champions of this tournament
against one-another. Paul Zingg won in 1991, and Jeff Hazel in 1998. It promises
to be a great match between two not-quite grizzled veterans.
Both of the semifinals matches in the first
flight ended with upsets. Steve Sanguinetti, the lowly 16th seed has been successfully
luring unsuspecting opponents over to the Peninsula Country Club, where he
ambushes them. As one who has been ambushed, I can vouch for the pleasantness of
the experience. It's like falling asleep at the wheel. It's so nice, but then
you wake up the next day in some cornfield, wondering what happened. Steve's
latest victim was Mark Holman (13th seed) who was defeated 2 up. Steve will next
be facing Ross Sakamoto, the 10th seed. Ross advanced by defeating his buddy
Rick Guevara (3rd seed) 2 and 1. Ross and Steve have both been the giant-killers
of the first flight. Steve took out Aaron Walburg (1st seed) in the opening
match, while Ross took out both Barry Woods (2nd seed) and Rick Guevara (3rd
seed). We'll have to see which giant-killer claims the grand prize.
The second flight is this year's anomaly. Both
of the top seeds advanced to the finals. Scott Meredith the #1 seed and
defending champion will be facing Kelly Alvarez, the #2 seed. Both players have
been scoring well of late so this should be exciting. Scott advanced by beating Bob
Sternbach 4 and 3. Alvarez advanced by beating Boyd McCaslin 6 and 4. These two
power houses will face off later this month. This match is important because
both players are in the midst of a tight GOY
race. Alvarez is in 4th place, 4 points behind Steve Desimone, while Scott is
in 5th, 5 points back. With 2 precious points in the balance this could be
crucial. By the way, Scott has won 7 consecutive matches and will be going for
number 8. In 2000, Steve Obana had a streak of 9-consecutive wins. More research
would have to be conducted to discover if 9 wins is a club record, but
doubtless, both streaks are impressive.
The Longest Match in UCGC History
An epic match took place during the quarterfinals in the Championship flight.
Jeff Hazel defeated David Moers 1up on the 24th hole. Playing at Poppy Ridge on
Sunday June 8th, they played the Zinfandel course followed by the Merlot course.
After 18 holes the match was even, so they proceeded over to the Chardonnay
course. After tying on five consecutive holes, Jeff won the sixth by paring the
hole while David earned a bogey. On of the players (I can't remember which) kept
sinking really long putts to remain in the match. They played out the remaining
three holes and thus played all 27 holes that day.
Championship Flight Final:
Paul Zingg ekes out close win at Black Horse
Paul Zingg defeated Jeff Hazel 1up at
Black Horse to win the Championship Flight in the Eddie Reed
tournament. They met on August 31st, about a month after the club played
Black Horse during its Monterey trip.
Both men had exactly the same August index (5.3) and the match lived
up to its exciting expectations. Paul eked out a 1up win by earning a par on the
18th hole. The gentlemen were even after the opening 10 holes, but Paul
fought to a lead of 3-up with 5 to go, after winning holes 11, 12, and
13. Jeff birdied two of the next three to cut the lead down to one hole.
A solid par by Paul on 18 sealed it. They'd played the back tees of the
difficult course. Paul shot an 80 and Jeff shot an 82. More details possibly to come...
1st Flight Final:
Against all common sense Ross visits Steve's house, and wins
Ross Sakamoto somehow defeated Steve
Sanguinetti 2 and 1 to capture the first flight. Steve Sanguinetti had
been ambushing unsuspecting visitors at his home course, the Peninsula
Country Club. The strategy was working like a charm for him all season.
For his first-ever Eddie Reed tournament, Steve played like a veteran. He was
the 16th seed and he advanced to the finals. That was huge in itself. Just as
all of his fallen predecessors had done, Ross went against all common-sense and accepted
Steve's offer to play his home course. Details are sketchy, but somehow
Ross survived. We'll keep digging up details as we're sure this story will be worth repeating
fow many years to come (if only to berate Steve who unceremoniously dispatched
the yours truly in the first round).
2nd Flight Final:
Kelly Alvarez Dethrones Defending Champ Scott Meredith
Sunday, August 24th, 2003, at the Paradise Valley Golf Course.
The Pre-Game Show:
- Both men are in the midst of a GOY battle: Alvarez in fourth place, 4
points behind the leader, Meredith in 6th place, 5 points behind the
leader. 2 points go to winner of match.
- Meredith, the defending champion of the second flight attempting to
win his 8th consecutive win.
- Alvarez tried to get Meredith out to Las Positas (where he ambushes
opponents), but Meredith wasn't buying! Meredith wanted to play Alameda
(where he ambushes opponents), but Alvarez wasn't buying! Finally they
arranged a match at Paradise where they both have played well and poorly
and which they both liked. It's 200 yards shorter than Las Positas but 200
yards longer than Alameda. A fair compromise.
- 10 days prior to the event Alvarez was contemplating withdrawing from
the tournament because of two bulging disks in his neck that had been
worsening over the previous two months. He was chewing vicoden's daily
just to get through the day at work. But, he'd been going to his
chiropractor every other day and his neck was finally responding. So he
setup the match with Meredith hoping it would hold up long enough to
complete the Eddie Reed.
- In spite of the pain, Kelly's been improving because he's been able to
practice and play a lot lately.
- Meredith was playing with a pounding headache, which got progressively
worse in the 90+ degree heat. (When he got home he downed 3 Motrin and
crashed).
- Alvarez received 24 strokes, Meredith 17 strokes. The played off
one-another's index and Alvarez therefore received 7 strokes.
The Battle:
Alvarez quickly jumped out to a 2-hole lead after the first three holes.
Scott eliminated that lead by the 6th hole and pulled ahead by one on the ninth
hole. Alvarez birdied the 10th hole (without need of the stroke he got on that
hole). The birdie possibly distracted Meredith, whose game fell apart,
whereupon he lost the next three holes, going down 3 after 13th. At the 16th tee
Alvarez was dormie, 3up with 3 to go. He proceeded to choke on the next two
holes which he lost, while Meredith was playing well. In true Eddie Reed Match
play fashion it came down to the 18th hole. (a hole Meredith says he couldn't
par if his life depended on it!) Alvarez is 1up at this point. Scott's first
shot was a safe play well short of the water, Alvarez boomed his drive through
the fairway, across the cart path, but with a good lie in deep grass. Meredith's
approach was well short, below and to the right of the green, 25 yards away.
Alvarez's approach was just short of the front edge of the green. The pin (blue)
was in the back right of the green (just over ten feet from back edge) and just
6-feet from the tier edge. Alvarez chipped to within 6 feet (just up to the tier
edge & lucky it didn't roll back). Scott pitched over the grassy knoll, but
12-feet from the pin and on the second tier. Assuming Alvarez would 2-putt for
the win (and having a stroke to burn), Meredith had to go for the pin. He ran
the putt past the pin by 6-feet. Alvarez also went for the pin because he wanted
to win without using his stroke ("A stupid play", Alvarez later said, "as echoed
by Russell Greenwood".) Alvarez made his come-backer and Scott missed his.
Alvarez won 2up.
The Aftermath:
Meredith was hoping we could just let the whole thing pass without any
mention of it on the web site or elsewhere. "This, you see, is my only hope of
erasing the day from my memory, but, alas I guess I'll have to live with
it until next season's Eddie Reed."
Alvarez's words of wisdom: "The only reason that I won (or even got this far)
was that every opponent that I faced shot above their index when playing against
me while I just shot to my index.". (Alvarez got 7 strokes but only four were used to
tie or win a hole. Alvarez shot 2 under par with his handicap. Meredith shot 3
over par with his handicap.)
Pre-Season Predictions
|
2003 Eddie Reed Match Play Tournament Begins
|
Defending Champion Steve Desimone is the number one seed in the
Championship flight. This not a mere coincidence, as Steve has won three of
the past four years. His lifetime match record is 38 wins and 13 loses. Steve
has the more
match play wins than any
member in club history, with 15 more wins than the next closest
active club member, Paul Zingg. Steve is again the favorite this year, however
there are other perennial contenders to consider. Ken Lloyd, Mark
Steppan, Jeff Hazel and Paul Zingg - all have performed well in match
play over the years. This year there's even some new blood, in the form
of Ryan Atkinson, whose 1.4 index currently matches Steve's.
In the First flight Defending Champ
Aaron Walburg is the number one seed. He has won 6 of his past 7
matches. His lifetime record is 7 and 3. Also keep an eye on 2001
Champion Barry Woods, Jimmy Ikeda, Rick Guevara and Andrew Kang.
Defending Champ Scott Meredith is the
favorite in the second Flight. Scott's lifetime record is 6 and 2, the
best winning percentage of all this year's defending champions. Scott
has received a tough draw this year, facing newcomer (and unknown
factor) Ryan Tabibian in the first round, then either Jack King or Tom
Furtado in the second round. Jack King was runner up in 2001, and Tom
Furtado has been playing remarkably over the past year. Other strong candidates in
the second flight are Bob Sternbach, currently 2nd in the GOY standings,
Russell Greenwood (currently 3rd), Kelly Alvarez, and Yoch Lin.
|
 |
| Defending Champ, Steve tries for
4 wins in past 5 years. |
 |
| Aaron favored in the 1st
flight. |
 |
| Scott favored in the 2nd
flight. |
 |
| Bob Sternbach's star is
rising. |
|
Preliminary Tournament Details
Mailings
Below are the mailings associated with the 2003 Eddie Reed
Tournament:
Schedule
Play may begin as early as April 1. The tournament will be
completed by September 1, just prior to the Club Championships.
Prizes
Glory is the biggest prize. What's more special than
standing before bitter fellow members and gloating. Flight winners and runner-ups also
receive trophies and cash, $50 for winners and $25 for runners-up.
Flights
The field is divided into
three flights: Championship, First, and Second. The First and Second
Flights will use indexes, the Championship Flight is played without any
handicaps. Each flight is broken down into two sub-brackets: Blue and
Gold. The winners of each sub-bracket will meet in the Finals. The winners
of each Finals match will be crowned winners of that flight at which point
the tournament will be completed.
Seedings
Seedings were made based on several factors:
-
Performances in this past Eddie Reed Championships
-
Performances in major tournaments
-
GOY standings
-
Performances in the first six events of the 2003
season.
Posting Scores
In match play you must
post. Also read about adjusting conceded
holes.
Eddie Reed GOY Point
Structure
At the board meeting on 11/8/00
it was decided that an additional point for participation was warranted in the
Eddie Reed tournament to make it so that all major events earn 2 points for
participation. With the Eddie Reed tournament, these participation points will
be granted upon the completion of the first round matches, however if in any
round a player forfeits or withdraws from a match, that player's participation
points shall be removed. Example of how the points work:
Round 1
Loser by forfeit or WD = 0 points for participation (total of 0 points earned)
Loser = 2 for participation (total of 2 points earned)
Winner = 2 points for win, 2 points for participation, advance (total of 4 points earned)
Round 2
Loser by forfeit or WD = 0 points for participation (total of 2 points earned)
Loser = 0 for loss (total of 4 points earned)
Winner = add 2 points(6 total), advance
Round 3
Loser by forfeit or WD = 0 points for participation (total of 4 points earned)
Loser = 0 for loss (total of 6 points earned)
Winner = add 2 points(8 total), advance
Round 4
Loser by forfeit or WD = 0 points for participation (total of 6 points earned)
Loser = 0 for loss (total of 8 points earned)
Winner = add 2 points(10 total), advance
|